Opinion | In the Yes Bank drama, RBI has shot itself in the foot

The central bank should embrace more transparency, with better explanations for regulatory actions.

There is this irrational joy mingled with relief that taxpayers feel on getting a tax refund, never mind that it was their money in the first place. Yes Bank investors too experienced that emotion last week when the lender revealed that RBI found its bad loan disclosures to be in apple-pie order, never mind that such compliance is basic hygiene and not an achievement to be tom-tommed.

Late Friday, RBI punctured that bubble by asking Yes Bank to issue another stock exchange notice saying that it violated regulations by revealing part of the findings of  the central bank audit. Further, the audit is said to have found other “lapses and regulatory breaches” in Yes Bank's functioning and the selective disclosure was “a deliberate attempt to mislead the public.”

In the last two years, this “divergence” data (the difference between a bank’s and RBI’s assessment of bad loans) has been key to bank stock valuations and much sought after. It is material data. Several banks have revealed this data through press releases, notes to quarterly accounts, in analyst conference calls and so on, as bank analyst Hemindra Hazari points out

If that’s the case, why has RBI picked on Yes Bank? The central has not upbraided any other lender, at least publicly.

Perhaps the problem is with the other lapses and regulatory breaches that RBI found. Both RBI and the Yes Bank communique are silent about these. If these are material, why haven’t these been disclosed? If they are non-material, does it matter?

In any case, RBI has been the role model of regulatory opaqueness. In the last two years, the central bank’s enforcement department has issued 128 penalties against financial institutions and collected around Rs 147.3 crore, says this report from BloombergQuint.

IF YOU WANT RISK-FREE TRADE, CHOOSE US FOR THE BEST RECOMMENDATIONS AND TAKE THE  ADVANTAGE OF INDIAN STOCK MARKET. CLICK HERE AND JOIN US FOR FREE >> Call Put Option Tips